The Fisker Karma is rolling onto the world automotive theatre as automobile writers in the U.S. and Europe inspect the automobile in person for the first time and take their primary laps at the behind of the wheel. They could positively be immune for saying the automobile and the author through rose-colored glasses. Both have been the recipient of more allege broadside than a Donald Trump presidential endorsement.

Henrik Fisker is the luminary automobile designer who wants to do well by you do good. His creation, the Karma, a $103,000 plug-in hybrid, has been pciking up “Car of the Yearawards by the trunkload. As the first four-door ultra-luxury gas-electric car, it has been distinguished by environmentalists, sanctified by the federal supervision with a on trial loan, and permitted by celebrities. Leo DiCaprio lighted a whirl of broadside when he took smoothness of the first prolongation model.

But those who haven’t been but eyes by the glisten of broadside are commencement to consternation either the Karma will be a strike similar to DiCaprio’s Titanic — or a wave similar to his Body of Lies. More keen reviewers find the automobile overweight, inefficient, and able of customarily common opening that falls well reduced of the strange eco-friendly goals.

Fisker is a 48-year-old Dane who done his repute conceptualizing BMWs and Aston Martins. He founded Fisker Automotive in 2007 and showed the judgment for the Karma 4 months after at the Detroit auto show. Production began haltingly scarcely a year ago at a stipulate manufacturer in Finland, and deliveries to dealers have just begun. Not prone to understatement, Fisker calls the Karma the accomplishment of “a lifelong mental condition of conceptualizing and formulating a operation of pleasing cars that make environmental sense but compromise.”

Like the Chevy Volt, the Karma is written to transport thirty to 45 miles on an electric assign prior to a gasoline engine kicks in. Unlike the $40,000 Volt, the extroverted Karma is unabashedly directed at one-percenters. Its lines are seductive and proportions unique. Fisker says the design was desirous by “the superb lines of windswept silt dunes and the robust beauty of a cheetah.” He showed his green side by wise out the interior in politically scold materials: The seating froth is done from soy-based bio fiber, the runner subsidy stoical of recycled post-consumer materials, and the trim sourced from “fallen, fallen and detected wood,” together with a little that has outlayed the last 300 years lazy at the bottom of Lake Michigan.

Inspired pattern is no surrogate for prolongation experience, however, and Fisker has encountered the common problems that come from starting up an enterprise as formidable as a automobile manufacturer: prolongation delays, prices hikes, and canceled orders. In December, Fisker removed all 239 cars built in between Jul 1 and Nov since of a probable complaint with the battery‘s cooling system. Early in February, it dangling prolongation and laid off twenty-six workers whilst it renegotiated conditions of the $529 million loan from the Department of Energy. Some have started to review Fisker to Solyndra, the unsuccessful solar row maker saved by the supervision to emanate green jobs.

When experts demeanour over the Karma’s drop-dead styling and investigate the car’s functionality, they find it wanting. After angry about “errant rattles here and there,” an admittedly round reviewer from Road & Track described rock climbing in to the driver’s chair as something of a “circus act” and declined to even make a try at removing in to the behind seats.

12 electric cars for 2012

More concrete complaints concentration on the car’s heft and fuel consumption. The Karma is customarily five inches shorter than a Ford Flex people-mover and customarily a couple of hundred pounds lighter than a Chevy Suburban — not just the measure you demeanour for in a competition sedan. The branch radius customarily looks considerable compared to a Kenworth hauling logs. Engineers at Consumer Reports figured that Fisker’s claims for a 50-mile all-electric operation are substantially confident (the EPA rates the Karma at 32 miles). They also detected that the increase in speed “lacks the coercion you’d design from a automobile of this cost and presence,” and the doing is “not at the spin a single would design from a sporty high-end sedan.” Consumer Reports concluded: “Whether [the Karma] is as green or as sporty as it ought to be stays to be seen.”

The many sardonic remarks to date came in the Mar emanate of the customarily lawful Car and Driver. (Full disclosure: I am an occasional contributor). It complained that whilst the Karma is a “heartthrob” to demeanour at, it is radically a $100,000 irrelevance and “not a receptive choice.”

To Car and Driver, the Karma comes off as a blivet — 10 pounds of element pressed in to a five-pound bag. The complaint is perplexing to fist all those batteries, two electric motors, and a roof-mounted solar row in to that seductive body. The outcome is bad wrapping and extreme weight. As the repository discovered, the Karma’s behind chair is not as big than a little Honda Fit’s and the case is reduction than half the distance of an similarly little Kia Rio’s. The Karma’s two and a half tons of avoirdupois levy a serious chastisement in fuel manage to buy — underneath both electric and gasoline power. Test drivers were customarily able to fist twenty-four to twenty-eight miles out of the battery, whilst the gas-only mileage ranged from twenty mpg to twenty-eight mpg — doubtful many awards from environmental groups. The repository concludes that the Mercedes-Benz S-class is cheaper than the Karma, the Lexus LS600 better built, and the Porsche Panamera faster, scarcely as economical, and $20,000 reduction expensive.

The Karma may nonetheless spin out to be an critical miracle on the approach to the all-electric automobile since it demonstrates that environmental attraction is not exclusive with oppulance and style. Or it could breeze up as an automotive bauble similar to the Tucker Torpedo or the DeLorean DMC-12 — as well desirous by a half.

View this essay on Fortune

More From Fortune

car – Yahoo! News Search Results